Can You Actually Tithe When You Don't Have Much?
The question comes up in pastoral conversations more than any other financial question I'm asked. Not "how do I invest?" or "how much should I save?" — it's this one: "I want to give, but I genuinely don't think I can afford to. Am I off the hook?"
It's an honest question, and it deserves an honest answer. Not a motivational answer. Not a "just trust God and the money will appear" answer. An honest one.
Here it is: the answer is complicated, and it depends on what you believe giving is actually for.
What Tithe Means and Where It Comes From
The word tithe comes from an Old English word for "tenth." In the Old Testament, Israel was commanded to give ten percent of their agricultural produce and livestock — the first and best of what the land yielded — as an act of worship, provision for the Levites (the priestly tribe who had no land of their own), and care for the poor. There were actually multiple tithes in the Mosaic law, amounting to somewhere between twenty and twenty-three percent of annual income when you add them up.
Evangelical Christians have generally read the tithe as a useful benchmark carried forward into the New Testament era — not as a legal requirement in the same sense as the Mosaic law (which Christ fulfilled), but as a reasonable starting point for generosity. Ten percent. Of your gross income, not your after-tax income. Given to your local church before you give to anything else.
That's the traditional teaching. And it's worth taking seriously.
But here's the tension: the New Testament doesn't repeat the tithe as a legal command the way the Old Testament does. What Paul says in 2 Corinthians 9:7 is this: "Each one must give as he has decided in his heart, not reluctantly or under compulsion, for God loves a cheerful giver." There's no percentage cited. The standard is cheerful — willing, decided, not coerced.
This doesn't mean "give whatever you feel like." The context of 2 Corinthians 9 is Paul encouraging the Corinthians to follow through on a generous pledge they'd already made. The point isn't that giving is optional. The point is that the spirit of giving matters — that compelled giving, given to avoid guilt, isn't what God is after.
Does That Mean the Tithe Is Optional?
I want to be careful here, because this is where a lot of sermons and articles get it wrong in both directions.
On one side: the legalistic position treats the tithe as a transaction. Give ten percent and God owes you financial blessing. This is prosperity gospel logic, even in subtle forms. It isn't biblical, and it's harmful to people who give faithfully and still face hardship.
On the other side: the "just give what you feel led to give" position, without any benchmark or expectation, tends to produce very little giving and lots of rationalisation. Human beings are remarkably good at convincing themselves that their current giving is sufficient.
The honest middle is this: ten percent is a useful, historically grounded benchmark that most Christians should aim toward — not because it's a legal requirement that earns God's favour, but because it's a discipline that shapes your relationship with money in important ways. It's a starting point, not a ceiling.
But What If You Genuinely Can't?
Now to the actual question.
If your income is CAD $3,500 per month and your rent is $1,800, your groceries are $600, your car (insurance, gas, maintenance) runs $500, utilities are $200, and your minimum debt payments are $400, you have exactly nothing left over. In that situation, ten percent of gross income — $350 — isn't available. It's not a discipline problem. It's math.
I'm not going to tell a man in that situation that he needs to tithe anyway and God will make up the difference. That's not pastoral care. That's magical thinking dressed in theological language. It can also cause real damage — families who tithe on money they don't have and then can't make rent are not honouring God with their giving; they're creating a crisis.
So what should that man do?
Start somewhere. Not nowhere — somewhere.
Giving nothing tends to produce a man who gives nothing indefinitely. There's a spiritual atrophy that comes from prolonged non-giving, a tightening of the hands around what you have, that is genuinely hard to reverse. Even a small, faithful amount — CAD $25 a month, $50, whatever creates a genuine gesture without creating genuine hardship — keeps the posture of giving alive.
The Discipline Beneath the Discipline
Here is what I've observed, in my own life and in conversations with men in my congregation: the discipline of giving isn't primarily about the amount. It's about what the giving does to you.
Giving regularly, even in small amounts, is a regular act of trust. It says: I believe there is enough. I believe that releasing some of what I have is not a loss. I believe that God's provision isn't contingent on my hoarding. These are statements of faith made in concrete action rather than just interior conviction.
When my wife and I were in our earliest financially stretched years — living on my income while she was in school, then attacking her student debt the moment she graduated — we gave a small, consistent amount to our church. It wasn't ten percent. We built toward that. But we gave something, and we didn't stop. The discipline built a habit that was easier to expand when the margin expanded.
I don't say this as a formula. Financial circumstances vary enormously. A man supporting a family on a single income in a high-cost city is in a genuinely different situation from a dual-income household with no dependents, and they both deserve honest advice that accounts for their actual situation.
A Practical Framework
If you want something concrete to work with:
Give first. Before you pay any discretionary expenses, set aside your giving amount — even if it's small. Giving from what's left over tends to produce consistently diminishing returns as the month goes on and the account shrinks.
Work toward ten percent as a goal, not a baseline of guilt. If you're giving two percent, aim for three. Then four. This is not the same as telling someone drowning in debt to give ten percent immediately. It's treating giving as a discipline that grows as capacity grows.
Count the giving you're already doing. If you're contributing to a food bank, helping a family member financially, supporting a missionary — these matter. A legalistic reading of the tithe sometimes erases the broader landscape of generosity a man is already practising.
Distinguish between "I can't afford it" and "I haven't made it a priority." This is a harder question and I put it gently, but it's worth asking. Some men who say they can't afford to give are technically right. Others are giving from the bottom of the month rather than the top, and finding nothing left because other things got there first. Only you and your actual budget know which is true.
The Widow's Offering and What It Actually Means
Jesus watches a widow drop two small coins in the temple treasury — the smallest denomination of currency available, worth practically nothing — and says she has given more than all the wealthy donors combined (Mark 12:41–44). Not because her amount was larger. Because it was everything she had.
The point of the story isn't "give until it genuinely hurts." The point is that God's economy measures giving differently than our economy does. The widow's gift wasn't a percentage of income. It was a posture of the heart — a complete entrusting of her material circumstances to God's care.
Most of us will not give like the widow. We're not meant to be reckless with money that supports our families. But the story does something important: it refuses to let us use the size of our giving as the measure of its value.
Give what you can. Give it cheerfully, not reluctantly. Give it first, not last. And keep your hands open.
The percentage matters less than the direction of travel.
Author: Dan Taylor
Site: Wise and Faithful
Published: April 9, 2026
Affiliate Disclosure
Affiliate disclosure: Some links in this article are referral links. If you sign up or purchase through them, I may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. I only link to products I personally use and recommend. Full disclosure.